Björn recenserade The Years of Rice and Salt av Kim Stanley Robinson
None
3 stjärnor
Torn about this, much like other KSRs I've read. Yes, his vision is incredible. Yes, his ideas are sometimes brilliant. Yes, when he digs into one aspect of this world, it's endlessly fascinating. Yet so often I find myself feeling like I don't get enough of either the macro nor the micro. He's so busy doing philosphy and theory of history that we don't get to sit in the actual storytelling often enough - especially when the history, as far as we can tell, doesn't really change beyond recognition. There's always a Columbus, always a Leonardo, always an Einstein, and KSR's utopianism feels like a teacher's edition a little too often.
And yet, when it is good, it's really good. This is one I imagine will stick in my head. I'll probably recommend it to people. Just with caveats.
Torn about this, much like other KSRs I've read. Yes, his vision is incredible. Yes, his ideas are sometimes brilliant. Yes, when he digs into one aspect of this world, it's endlessly fascinating. Yet so often I find myself feeling like I don't get enough of either the macro nor the micro. He's so busy doing philosphy and theory of history that we don't get to sit in the actual storytelling often enough - especially when the history, as far as we can tell, doesn't really change beyond recognition. There's always a Columbus, always a Leonardo, always an Einstein, and KSR's utopianism feels like a teacher's edition a little too often.
And yet, when it is good, it's really good. This is one I imagine will stick in my head. I'll probably recommend it to people. Just with caveats.