Björn recenserade Girl in a band av Kim Gordon
None
3 stjärnor
3.5/5, a solid 4/5 if you're specifically looking for Sonic Youth info. Kim Gordon is not a bad writer, and if she's no Patti Smith, that's ... well, who is. Girl In A Band is a good memoir, but doesn't frequently rise above "Here's what happened to me specifically" into saying something more about the scene, about music, about art. It happens enough to make it worthwhile, and as a fan I lap up all the personal stuff too, but...
I was lucky enough to see SY several times. I saw 71-year-old Kim Gordon play solo last year and it was one of the best shows I've been to in years, closer to the anti-rock scene SY sprang from than anything they'd done since the mid-80s while sounding nothing like them. I kind of wish that's the Kim who wrote this, someone who'd moved on and become a vibrant creative …
3.5/5, a solid 4/5 if you're specifically looking for Sonic Youth info. Kim Gordon is not a bad writer, and if she's no Patti Smith, that's ... well, who is. Girl In A Band is a good memoir, but doesn't frequently rise above "Here's what happened to me specifically" into saying something more about the scene, about music, about art. It happens enough to make it worthwhile, and as a fan I lap up all the personal stuff too, but...
I was lucky enough to see SY several times. I saw 71-year-old Kim Gordon play solo last year and it was one of the best shows I've been to in years, closer to the anti-rock scene SY sprang from than anything they'd done since the mid-80s while sounding nothing like them. I kind of wish that's the Kim who wrote this, someone who'd moved on and become a vibrant creative musician again, rather than a newly-divorced Kim looking to set the record straight.